Directed by the legendary Frank Capra, Forbidden is a quintessential Pre-Code “women’s picture”—a genre known for its frank exploration of sacrifice, illegitimate romance, and social boundaries. This film is a stark departure from the populist comedies Capra would later become famous for, offering instead a gritty, decades-spanning melodrama.
The Synopsis
The story follows Lulu Smith, a lonely and frustrated librarian who decides to gamble her meagre life savings on a luxury cruise to Havana, hoping to finally find adventure and romance. On the ship, she meets the charming and wealthy Bob Grover. The two fall deeply in love, but upon returning to the city, Lulu discovers a devastating secret: Bob is already married to a woman who is an invalid, and he is a rising political star with a reputation to maintain.
Unwilling to part, the two begin a secret, long-term affair. As the years pass, Bob rises to the position of District Attorney and eventually Governor, while Lulu remains his “hidden” companion, living in the shadows and making increasingly painful sacrifices to protect his career and public image. The drama intensifies with the arrival of Al Holland, a cynical and ambitious journalist who suspects the truth and is determined to expose the scandal to destroy Bob’s political future. Lulu is forced to decide just how much of her own life and soul she is willing to give up to keep the man she loves on his pedestal.
Cast & Crew
| Role | Name |
| Director | Frank Capra |
| Lulu Smith | Barbara Stanwyck |
| Bob Grover | Adolphe Menjou |
| Al Holland | Ralph Bellamy |
| Helen Grover | Dorothy Revier |
Production Notes
-
The Stanwyck-Capra Connection: This was the third of five collaborations between Barbara Stanwyck and Frank Capra. Capra famously credited Stanwyck with teaching him how to direct “real” emotion, and her performance here is a tour de force, as she ages twenty years over the course of the film.
-
Pre-Code Liberty: Because the film was released before the strict enforcement of the Hays Code in 1934, it deals with themes of “living in sin” and illegitimate children with a level of realism and empathy that would have been censored just a few years later.
-
A “Back Street” Narrative: The plot bears a strong resemblance to the famous novel Back Street by Fannie Hurst. While Capra’s film was an original screenplay, it contributed significantly to the “suffering woman” subgenre that dominated 1930s cinema.
-
Visual Evolution: Capra uses subtle changes in lighting and costume to mirror Lulu’s transition from a naive librarian to a hardened, world-weary woman, highlighting the physical and emotional toll of her “forbidden” life.
